Opinions
about 'Kojak - 50 Seconds of Television Music'
“Tagg’s
procedure is an imaginative synthesis of work in many fields and opens
the way to an extraordinarily broad and inviting research domain… The
most pregnant assertions in this work, which involve the reaffirmation
and formalisation of a hermeneutical approach to music, are fully convincing.
Their fertility is attested by the richness of the analytical example
provided.”
(Bill Brooks in Svensk tidskrift för musikforskning)
“refreshing”,
“heroic scholarship” (Mark Steedman in Popular Music)
“Such detailed
discussion of 50 seconds of everyday TV music may seem excessive, but
the stimulating approach and results of Tagg’s work make for really worthwhile
reading and suggest the opposite.”
(Andreas Ballstaedt in Musikforschung)
Taggs
books are the only academic works, on music in media, that dare pull off
the muses mask. In this they provide a useful and practical way
of thinking that can help those of us involved in the industrial process
that Hollywood music is today.
Peter D Kaye, music editor and composer, Santa Monica.
“If Tagg
were in a context in which music semiotics existed as a matter of course,
he could simply refer. But, unfortunately, most of his steps are absolutely
necessary – he has to rebuild the whole of Western musical semiotics before
he can unpack the theme from Kojak.”
(Susan McClary and Rob Walser in On Record)
“a major
paradigm shift in musicology” (Jan Ling)
“Official
musicology seems to know no better than to concern itself with the music
of a highly selective and particular part of society. In this sense Tagg
is like the one-eyed man in the land of the blind because his approaches
are new. They should have been developed and tested decades ago.”
(Leo Sanama in Haagse Post)
“richly suggestive”...
“Tagg’s approach works well”
(Richard Middleton in Studying Popular Music)
“An extraordinary
book on an extraordinary topic… uniquely original, comprehensive and pioneering…
Musicologists interested in the secrets of musical mass influence must
read this book. I am sure that anybody concerned with complex analysis,
semiology, and especially with multi-channel processes of contemporary
audiovisual media can find here abundant sources of inspiration.”
(János Maróthy in Studia Musicologica Academiae Scientiarum
Hungaricae)
Top |